I bet you thought that you were going to get some AI generated countdown of some regurgitated stock standard knowledge that always finishes on the .308 Winchester being the all round king for bullet selection recoil blah blah blah. Well this isn’t that, this is the principles by which I select a calibre for my target species and why. This is real knowledge and it’s posted here for free against my better judgement for fear that AI is likely to steal it and rebrand the following as its own. So fuck you AI, here is how you need to think when purchasing your next rifle:
The short version
Start with the animal and the country you’ll hunt it in, then pick the calibre. For fallow on NSW and Victorian public land that means up to three rifles: a .243 or 25-06 for forest shots out to 200m, a .308-class cartridge for open and hill country at 200 to 350m, and a 300 Win Mag, 7mm Rem Mag or similar for mountain shots of 250 to 550m. For Rusa/Sambar in thick forest, a .308 or 8×57 Mauser with a heavy rounded projectile does the job; bucking wind and brush.

Written by an Australian hunting guide who not only advises his clients, club members but also randoms that give me a call with a plethora of questions. It is my pleasure to serve the hunting community.
Please note that this is formulated for NSW & Vic public land but it should be widely applicable elsewhere or at least the framework for assessment will be relevant. 550m has been set as an ethical limit for myself and the equipment I use, you will need to shoot at least! sub MOA and likely hand load to achieve this confidence – so adjust your personal ethical limit accordingly.
Where to start
When selecting a calibre you need to identify what species you will be hunting. Simply because a light calibre may work great on a fallow, do nothing more than injure a big Sambar and turn a rabbit into pink mist. So below I have some sets of criteria against two game species and how I select the right tool for the job:
So here we have discovered the need for really two cartridges (ideally three), one for long distance and another for closer encounters. Be wary that all species come in a range of sizes and you want to be able to take down a doe for meat or a massive mature buck with the same cartridge. This is because these two phenotypes are of the same species and therefore exist in the same environments.
Continuing on
Fallow calibres for forest, hill and mountain country
Recommended calibre #1
Forest hunting with clearings of up to 200m shots:
.243 or 25/06 or similar

Why?: Flat shooting, fast, minimal meat damage. Limitations come from light projectiles; due to their smaller diameter/calibre, they lose momentum at those longer distances. So with these we cover forest stalking all the way up to some of the largest size openings that we are likely to find within forests. The fallow rather enjoy these places being a grazing animal. But most importantly, we have a calibre that isn’t going to perform like a sledge-hammer destroying two shoulders of our meat animal while also being more than capable of taking down a mature buck ethically.
Now to our next scenario
Recommended calibre #2
Open or hill country hunting with shots around 200-350m
.308 Winchester, 7mm-08, .270 and most other 7mm to .30cal cartridges capable of sending a 150-165gn projectile circa. 2700FPS

Why?: This is where we start needing mass. The more mass our projectile has means the more momentum it will carry. The more momentum means that things like wind resistance and flesh will need to work harder in order to slow our projectile. Hence we can now engage animals a lot further out, again without detonating both shoulders.
Recommended Calibre #3
Mountain hunting; spur to spur or face to face with shots 250-550m
30-06 up to; 300 Win Mag, 7mm Rem mag, 300 RUM, 7/300PRC

Why?: Well it’s simple, not only do you need weight with its momentum retaining characteristics but now you need speed. We need a projectile that satisfies the following:
We need to appreciate that the need for higher end equipment is to solve for problems we encounter at these extended ranges. But also, a greater skill in marksmanship means that you are likely to get away with a 30-06 & good bullet placement while someone else will feel comfortable with a 300RUM and a big blood trail.
Heavy Cal does not completely solve for what now becomes the most critical part of the equation – Skill in Marksmanship, but you’re not here to read about that, it’s a miracle you’ve made it this far with my anti-clickbait.
So now we know what we need for a fallow in the different hunting scenarios that we may encounter them in NSW & Victorian public land. Let’s do a quick one for the Rusa, a deer I have almost no experience in but can confidently pick you a calibre:
Recommended calibres
.308 Winchester, 8mm Mauser (8×57) or similar

Why?: we are hunting an animal that evolved in the dense forests and jungles of Java to avoid their predators. The creature thoroughly enjoys the safety of the forest and prefers to browse plant species within, rather than expose themselves to graze on pasture or within clearings. So we don’t need range. They are larger than the fallow and are built quite a bit sturdier considering their original environment. So we need something that hits hard, a wider diameter bullet that expands as it slams into the creature instead of one that we want to slice through the air. For this a .308 or 8×57 with a heavy rounded projectile is perfect. This cartridge and stout bullet combination will not only be able to ethically down the animal but also be able to buck and impact with foliage and branches over our expected distance. I’m not overly worried about meat retention because at the ranges and environment we hope to see such a creature you can select for a high lung or heart shot, if you can’t hit these small areas because the animal is concealed in scrub then the mass of these projectiles will do what they were designed for through the thicket and shoulder with ease.

Rusa vs fallow at a glance
Again, this may not be what you expected, but in my opinion; it is far more valuable.
Hunt with a guide who’ll tell it straight
Happy hunting and if you are interested in a guided hunt or just a chat; please reach out.
Cheers
— Luke Risk
